Actor Daniel Craig's Performance as James Bond
Tuesday, November 18, 2008
I had half a mind to go and see Quantum of Solace this weekend. The problem is that I am still not convinced by actor Daniel Craig playing the part of James Bond. It gets down to the perennial "Who is your favorite Bond?" question again. I am not saying that Daniel Craig doesn't give a good performance as Bond, I just think he misses some of the qualities that made some of the other lead actors in the role so much better.
Now some people like to argue about the character as portrayed by Ian Fleming in the original books. I have actually read a couple of the original books and my opinion is that the films are so far removed from the books of the same name as to be largely irrelevant to this argument. My own favorite Bond, along with most other people, was Sean Connery. The sardonic humour which was the hallmark of the Connery version of Bond was certainly not in the book and, being the first, he was always going to set the benchmark.
Everyone hated George Lazenby's performance, mainly I think because he wasn't Connery. I saw OHMS again on TV sometime later after the film came out and I thought it was actually not a bad Bond film overall. I think Lazenby's main problem was that he just didn't look right for the part - not enough distinctive character.
Then came Roger Moore of course. I didn't think he was too bad in the role. 'Diamonds Are Forever' is one of my favorite Bond movies, and 'Live and Let Die' wasn't too bad either. But the franchise was losing its way by then and Moore's replacement, Tim Dalton was a disaster - too dandified with no sense of toughness at all.
Thus, when Pierce Brosnon came in after something of a hiatus in the Bond story, there was much anticipation. I have to say that I thought Brosnon gave a sterling performance as Bond. The thing I liked most about Brosnon was that he bought an element of ruthlessness not previously displayed by the previous actors, including Connery. I thought it made the character much more believable (if that is the right word). Definitely the best casting since Connery in my opinion.
The common theme with all the Bonds has been that he has been played as a debonnair character - one who like his Martinis "shaken, not stirred". Bond as played by Craig has the quintessential Englishness of Bond but without Bond's sophistication. Craig's character is that of a working class tough and that, to me, may be the big problem with casting Craig in the role. I wasn't convinced by his performance in Casino Royale - its not that it was particularly a bad performance, its just that it just wasn't 'Bond'. I'm still of two minds whether I will see Quantum of Solace - the reviews don't seem particularly encouraging. If Pierce Brosnon was in it I think I would definitely go to see it - I'm still not entirely sure why they wanted to replace him in the first place.
Labels: actor, Daniel Craig, George Lazenby, James Bond, Pierce Brosnan, Quantum of Solace, Roder Moore, Sean Connery, Tim Dalton






